Assyro AI
US FDAUnited StatesALApproval Letter

Approval Letter Other 206089 (Jan 1, 2019)

Issued January 1, 2019

Issued

January 1, 2019

Application

Other • 206089

Review center

Other

Stage

Final Decision

Letter type

Approval Letter

Response due January 1, 2020Product may be marketed.

Summary

The FDA issued a Complete Response letter for Clarus Therapeutics, Inc.'s New Drug Application (NDA) for testosterone undecanoate (TU) (oral), indicating that the application cannot be approved in its present form due to several deficiencies related to safety, analytical methods, and nonclinical studies.

Key points

  • Propose detailed strategies in labeling (Boxed Warning, Indication, Contraindication, Warnings and Precautions) and beyond labeling (Risk Evaluation and Mitigation Strategy with elements to assure safe use) to mitigate cardiovascular risks associated with Jatenzo's blood pressure increases.
  • Conduct a study comparing total testosterone (T) concentrations measured from serum in plain tubes and plasma in NaF/EDTA tubes at different time points and temperature conditions to determine the rate and extent of TU to T ex vivo conversion.
  • Prespecify the maximum acceptable T concentration overestimation from TU to T ex vivo conversion in the study protocol.
  • Conduct a study comparing total T concentrations from serum (plain tubes) and plasma (NaF/EDTA and non-NaF tubes) in the same subjects without TU administration, with samples split, prepared, and analyzed in the same bioanalytical laboratory, including correlation analysis.
  • Submit protocols for the T concentration comparison studies for FDA review before initiation.
  • Include bioanalytical method validation and study reports for all matrices (serum, plasma, plasma in the presence of NaF) in the NDA resubmission.
  • Ensure accurate and reliable T tests intended for use with NaF/EDTA plasma specimens are available by the time of approval, potentially involving a companion diagnostic.
  • Provide data demonstrating the rate of TU cross-reactivity with commonly used immunoassays if commercial assays are used for measuring T in patients treated with the product.

Cited reasons

  • Clinically meaningful increases in blood pressure and cardiovascular risk
  • Inaccurate and irreproducible total testosterone concentration measurements
  • Inadequate nonclinical studies for fertility and carcinogenicity
  • The FDA issued a Complete Response Letter for Jatenzo due to significant safety concerns regarding clinically meaningful increases in blood pressure and associated cardiovascular risk, fundamental issues with the accuracy and reproducibility of total testosterone concentration measurements, and unacceptable nonclinical studies for fertility and carcinogenicity due to inadequate dosing and study design.

Recommended actions

  • Propose detailed strategies in labeling (Boxed Warning, Indication, Contraindication, Warnings and Precautions) and beyond labeling (Risk Evaluation and Mitigation Strategy with elements to assure safe use) to mitigate cardiovascular risks associated with Jatenzo's blood pressure increases.
  • Conduct a study comparing total testosterone (T) concentrations measured from serum in plain tubes and plasma in NaF/EDTA tubes at different time points and temperature conditions to determine the rate and extent of TU to T ex vivo conversion.
  • Prespecify the maximum acceptable T concentration overestimation from TU to T ex vivo conversion in the study protocol.
  • Conduct a study comparing total T concentrations from serum (plain tubes) and plasma (NaF/EDTA and non-NaF tubes) in the same subjects without TU administration, with samples split, prepared, and analyzed in the same bioanalytical laboratory, including correlation analysis.
  • Submit protocols for the T concentration comparison studies for FDA review before initiation.
  • Include bioanalytical method validation and study reports for all matrices (serum, plasma, plasma in the presence of NaF) in the NDA resubmission.
  • Ensure accurate and reliable T tests intended for use with NaF/EDTA plasma specimens are available by the time of approval, potentially involving a companion diagnostic.
  • Provide data demonstrating the rate of TU cross-reactivity with commonly used immunoassays if commercial assays are used for measuring T in patients treated with the product.

Deficiency summary

The FDA issued a Complete Response Letter for Jatenzo due to significant safety concerns regarding clinically meaningful increases in blood pressure and associated cardiovascular risk, fundamental issues with the accuracy and reproducibility of total testosterone concentration measurements, and unacceptable nonclinical studies for fertility and carcinogenicity due to inadequate dosing and study design.

Findings

Clinically meaningful increases in blood pressure and cardiovascular risk

Severity: critical

Jatenzo caused clinically meaningful increases in blood pressure, including a daytime average systolic blood pressure (SBP) increase of 5.0 mmHg, with larger increases in hypertensive subjects. This led to a higher rate of new or increased antihypertensive medication use compared to the comparator. The agency concluded these risks outweigh the benefits for many men due to increased risk of major cardiovascular adverse events.

Recommended response: Propose detailed strategies in labeling (Boxed Warning, Indication, Contraindication, Warnings and Precautions) and strategies beyond labeling, such as a Risk Evaluation and Mitigation Strategy (REMS) with elements to assure safe use, to mitigate risks and ensure a favorable benefit/risk profile.

Inaccurate and irreproducible total testosterone concentration measurements

Severity: major

The proposed method of monitoring patients using total testosterone (T) concentrations from plasma in NaF/EDTA tubes is problematic. The extent to which NaF/EDTA tubes prevent TU to T ex vivo conversion is unknown, and observed differences between sample types may be due to varying temperatures and LC-MS/MS methods. Further investigation of ex vivo conversion and potential cross-reactivity of immunoassays with TU is warranted.

Recommended response: Conduct studies comparing T concentrations from serum in plain tubes and plasma in NaF/EDTA tubes under various conditions, prespecify acceptable overestimation, evaluate plasma without NaF, include bioanalytical method validation reports, ensure accurate and reliable T tests are available, and provide data on TU cross-reactivity with immunoassays. A new Phase 3 trial may be needed if accuracy cannot be confirmed.

Inadequate nonclinical studies for fertility and carcinogenicity

Severity: critical

The submitted nonclinical studies are unacceptable. TU doses were inadequate to characterize chronic effects on male fertility and carcinogenicity, lacking sufficient exposure and toxicokinetic data. The 6-month carcinogenicity study in male Tg·rasH2 mice did not identify the maximally tolerated dose (MTD) and was insufficiently powered for one sex, failing to meet ICH guidance S1C(R2).

Recommended response: Provide justification for dose selection for the fertility study and conduct a new, adequately designed carcinogenicity study, submitting the protocol for review. Alternatively, classify the NDA as a 505(b)(2) application and provide appropriate nonclinical published literature references to address deficiencies.

Regulatory context

Submission stage
final decision
Regulatory pathway
505(b)(1) NDA

Impact

Impact score
0.95
Estimated delay
730 days
Estimated rework cost
$0
Subsequent action
resubmission

Strategic insights

The application was not approved due to significant unmitigated cardiovascular safety risks, fundamental issues with the reliability of clinical monitoring assays, and critical deficiencies in the nonclinical safety assessment, particularly regarding fertility and carcinogenicity studies.

Regulatory change impact: Pending sponsor mitigation plan

Approval likelihood after response: 5%

Document viewer

Read the FDA letter and send context to the co-pilot at any time.

Loading document viewer…