Assyro AI
US FDAUnited StatesCRLComplete Response Letter

Complete Response Letter BLA 761212 (Nov 14, 2024)

Issued November 14, 2024

Issued

November 14, 2024

Application

BLA • 761212

Review center

CBER

Stage

Final Decision

Letter type

Complete Response Letter

Response due November 14, 2025Requires resubmission addressing deficiencies.

Summary

This letter from the FDA outlines deficiencies in a Biologics License Application (BLA) for a biosimilar product, providing specific instructions for a safety update, proprietary name resubmission, and general resubmission procedures to achieve approval.

Key points

  • Review FDA guidance for industry Labeling for Biosimilar Products.
  • Resubmit the proposed proprietary name after addressing all application deficiencies.
  • Include a safety update with data from all nonclinical and clinical studies, regardless of indication, dosage form, or dose level.
  • Describe significant changes or findings in the safety profile and their relevance to differences between the proposed biosimilar and the U.S.-licensed reference product.
  • Incorporate new safety data into sections describing discontinuations due to adverse events, serious adverse events, and common adverse events, presenting new data in the same format as the original BLA submission.
  • Present tabulations of new safety data combined with original BLA data.
  • Include tables comparing frequencies of adverse events in the original BLA with retabulated frequencies.
  • Present a retabulation of reasons for premature study discontinuation, incorporating drop-outs from newly completed studies, and describe any new trends or patterns.

Cited reasons

  • Proprietary Name Resubmission
  • Comprehensive Safety Update Required
  • Inadequate Safety Data Presentation
  • Retabulation of Premature Study Discontinuations
  • Missing Case Report Forms and Narratives
  • Analysis of Common Adverse Event Incidence
  • Updated Clinical Exposure Information
  • Worldwide Safety Experience and Immunogenicity

Recommended actions

  • Review FDA guidance for industry Labeling for Biosimilar Products.
  • Resubmit the proposed proprietary name after addressing all application deficiencies.
  • Include a safety update with data from all nonclinical and clinical studies, regardless of indication, dosage form, or dose level.
  • Describe significant changes or findings in the safety profile and their relevance to differences between the proposed biosimilar and the U.S.-licensed reference product.
  • Incorporate new safety data into sections describing discontinuations due to adverse events, serious adverse events, and common adverse events, presenting new data in the same format as the original BLA submission.
  • Present tabulations of new safety data combined with original BLA data.
  • Include tables comparing frequencies of adverse events in the original BLA with retabulated frequencies.
  • Present a retabulation of reasons for premature study discontinuation, incorporating drop-outs from newly completed studies, and describe any new trends or patterns.

Deficiency summary

The application received a Complete Response Letter primarily due to significant deficiencies in the safety update, including inadequate presentation of clinical safety data, missing case report forms and narratives for serious adverse events, and insufficient worldwide safety experience. Additionally, English translations of foreign labeling are required, and the proprietary name cannot be approved until all other deficiencies are resolved.

Findings

Proprietary Name Resubmission

Severity: minor

The proposed proprietary name was found conditionally acceptable but requires resubmission once all other application deficiencies identified in this letter have been addressed.

Recommended response: Address all clinical and safety deficiencies before resubmitting the proprietary name for final approval.

Comprehensive Safety Update Required

Severity: major

Provide a comprehensive safety update including data from all nonclinical and clinical studies, describing in detail any significant changes or findings in the safety profile and their relevance to potential clinically meaningful differences between the proposed biosimilar product and the U.S.-licensed reference product.

Recommended response: Conduct a thorough review of all safety data, both nonclinical and clinical, and provide a detailed update that clearly addresses any significant changes or differences compared to the reference product.

Inadequate Safety Data Presentation

Severity: major

Present new safety data from clinical studies for the proposed indication using the same format as the original BLA submission. Include tabulations of new safety data combined with original BLA data, and tables comparing frequencies of adverse events between the original BLA and retabulated frequencies.

Recommended response: Reformat and retabulate all safety data to ensure consistency with the original BLA submission, providing clear comparative analyses of adverse event frequencies.

Retabulation of Premature Study Discontinuations

Severity: major

Present a retabulation of the reasons for premature study discontinuation by incorporating drop-outs from newly completed studies. Describe any new trends or patterns identified.

Recommended response: Update and analyze all discontinuation data from clinical studies, identifying and explaining any new trends or patterns.

Missing Case Report Forms and Narratives

Severity: critical

Provide case report forms and narrative summaries for each subject who died during a clinical study or who did not complete a study because of an adverse event. Additionally, provide narrative summaries for all serious adverse events.

Recommended response: Compile and submit all requested case report forms and detailed narrative summaries for all deaths and serious adverse events to ensure complete safety documentation.

Analysis of Common Adverse Event Incidence

Severity: major

Describe any information that suggests a substantial change in the incidence of common, but less serious, adverse events between the new data and the original BLA data.

Recommended response: Perform a comparative analysis of common adverse event incidences between new and original data, providing explanations for any significant changes observed.

Updated Clinical Exposure Information

Severity: major

Provide updated exposure information for the clinical studies, including details such as the number of subjects and person time.

Recommended response: Update and submit all clinical exposure data to reflect the most current and complete information.

Worldwide Safety Experience and Immunogenicity

Severity: major

Provide a summary of worldwide experience on the safety of this product, including adverse events known to be associated with its use and immunogenicity. Include an updated estimate of use for this product marketed in other countries.

Recommended response: Compile and submit a comprehensive summary of global safety data, including immunogenicity and market usage, for the product.

Missing English Translations of Foreign Labeling

Severity: major

Provide English translations of current approved foreign labeling that have not been previously submitted.

Recommended response: Obtain and submit certified English translations of all current approved foreign labeling documents.

Regulatory context

Submission stage
final decision
Regulatory pathway
BLA

Impact

Impact score
0.95
Estimated delay
365 days
Estimated rework cost
$0
Subsequent action
resubmission

Strategic insights

The primary theme of the Complete Response Letter is the inadequacy of the safety data package, requiring comprehensive updates, detailed analyses, and complete documentation of adverse events and worldwide experience. Labeling compliance, specifically foreign labeling translations, also needs to be addressed.

Regulatory change impact: Pending sponsor mitigation plan

Approval likelihood after response: 5%

Document viewer

Read the FDA letter and send context to the co-pilot at any time.

Loading document viewer…